Tuesday 3 September 2019

The Male Animal (1942 Elliott Nugent)

Considering the credits - James Thurber story, Epstein brothers screenplay, Warners, cast - something went wrong. College professor Henry Fonda is dealing with wife Olivia de Havilland's ex-flame Jack Carson and facing censorship from college (Eugene Pallette) over threatened reading of Vanzetti letter to class.

Despite the writers it isn't particularly funny, and the marital bust-up thing is just annoying and lacking in credibility (Olivia bursting into tears at any moment, Fonda unable to handle about two drinks). And too much football stuff.

In a sort of mirror, actually quite a good mirror, the sub-plot has daughter Joan Leslie being dated by football jock Don DeFore (a ridiculous 29) and intellectual Herbert Anderson (slightly better: 25).

No problem with Arthur Edeson's photography nor with Ivan F Simpson as supportive Dean, nor Hattie McDaniel - though she's seems to be relegated to a basically nice but slightly dotty housekeeper role again - a retrograde step.


No comments:

Post a Comment