The Holiday (2006 Nancy Myers & scr)

What's wrong with this film? I don't understand the negative reviews. Jude Law ("I sew and I have a cow") is super charismatic against Cameron Diaz (whose film trailer voiceover moments are great), Kate Winslet sweet with Jack Black and veteran screenwriter Eli Wallach, who quotes Lubitsch in his 'meet cute' example:

Kate excited about having a pool:

Also with Rufus Sewell.

The way that dog suddenly pops up from nowhere though is just WRONG.

Shot by Dean Cundey and scored by Hans Zimmer.